I would love to start answering to the last question,because from that you can find the answer for all the other problems.
Personally i consider insult a kind of violence: like Kicking or punching with words, a violent behaviour that exceed all capacity to face problems with reason and tolerance.
Zero tolerance is the answer to this kind of behaviour (toward Partecipants and members), even if the zero tolerance can be considered itself a form of violence.
So Insult is an insult when is just expression of violence, and the context of the post reveals if is just violence or “excess of argument”.
If it is just violence in my opinion it cannot be tolerated, in the other case the author of post can be cautioned about his behaviour.
Who can judge that ?
Personally i’d prefer to leave the judgement to the community or at least give the community a way to express if something is an insult or not: a moderator able to understand the feeling of the community would be a great solution to the problem.
I think they’ve not invented yet such sophisticated algorithm able to support this function, so better let technology do things she can do.
This way of thinking implies anyhow that If it is a community of Trolls nothing will be considered an insult.
Liberty of speech: i think the community is the key in this case as well.
The advantage of living in a virtual community is this (unlike the real community) that if you don’t like it anymore, you can move away - or participate less - and not be harmed by the fact that you are moving away.
Therefore not all the rules that apply to real community also apply to the virtual community.
To be clearer: If a certain language on Facebook is not tolerable, because Facebook has become an extension of the real community, in a hypothetical “Old Pigs Anonymous” community, certain language can be tolerated.
It might be time to decide what kind of community the Forum wants to be with a serious and honest examination of why we are all here.
To the point that started the topic: i think that @JamesDeen23 your way of support your opinion has more violence than arguments and for that it disturbed me a lot.
I’ve been moderator in a lot of places and i always followed an old rule: “do not feed the Troll” (and when a Troll feeds himself, kick him).
Thanks to anyone had the patience to read me.